Back to all articles

THE OWNER'S NOTEBOOK / Choosing a manager

How to compare two vacation rental revenue projections

Put two management proposals on the same calendar, check which homes they use as comparisons, and separate projected room revenue from the owner payout.

Two managers can look at the same home and produce different revenue estimates without disagreeing about what guests will pay. One may have counted nights you intend to use yourself. The other may have included guest cleaning charges in the total. Before choosing a proposal, ask both managers to show the calculation for one month you know well.

01

Give both managers the same calendar

Mark the first night you can actually host, the last night of your operating season, owner visits and planned work. Give each manager the same version. For a Michigan cottage you plan to use for a summer reunion, identify the exact nights rather than saying that the family visits occasionally. Ask which nights the forecast assumes will be offered and which it expects to sell. A blocked July weekend and an open November weekday cannot simply be exchanged on paper at a uniform annual rate.

02

Look at the homes behind the estimate

Ask for a few examples and why a guest choosing your home might also choose each one. A nearby cottage with private waterfront is a different proposition from one with public lake access a drive away. Check sleeping arrangements, actual amenities and the seasons the homes operate. AirDNA, for example, describes using nearby properties with similar bedroom, bathroom and guest counts when estimating performance. Ask what happens to the comparison if the least similar home is removed. A small or imperfect comparison set is useful when its limits are visible.

03

Rebuild a month on one line

Here is a hypothetical example, not a Michigan benchmark. Proposal A assumes 30 nights offered, 60% booked and $200 per booked night: 18 nights times $200 gives $3,600 in room revenue. Proposal B excludes five owner nights, assumes 64% of the remaining 25 nights book, and uses $210 per booked night: 16 nights times $210 gives $3,360. B assumes both a higher rate and higher occupancy, yet projects less room revenue. To isolate the calendar difference, ask A to rerun the same 25 nights. At unchanged assumptions its arithmetic becomes 15 nights times $200, or $3,000. In a real forecast, removing particular dates might also change the expected rate and occupancy.

04

Draw a line between revenue and money paid to you

Ask for a written definition of each total. Does it include accommodation only, cleaning charges, or something else? If the next line is labeled owner payout, request the deductions used to get there and whether costs paid directly by you are omitted. An advertised nightly price for an available home is not proof that a guest booked it at that price. Label historical booking records, modeled estimates and asking prices separately so you know what evidence you are comparing.

05

Take this request to your next proposal meeting

Ask: “For one month, please show the nights offered, expected paid nights, average accommodation rate, room revenue, other amounts included and estimated deductions. Which inputs come from my home, which come from comparable listings, and what changes if I reserve my preferred weekend?” Keep the dated answers with each proposal. If you proceed, compare the first completed period with those assumptions and identify whether a difference came from availability, nights sold, rate or expenses. That gives you a more useful conversation than asking why one annual total missed another.

Reference and next reading

AirDNA describes one provider’s estimation method. The worked comparison above is illustrative and does not use a property forecast or imply that Roava uses this tool. How AirDNA selects comparable listings for Rentalizer.

Continue with Vacation rental occupancy rates: ask which nights are being counted.

Bring the plan back to your property.

Discuss your home, current arrangements and the support you want with Roava. Service coverage, fees and responsibilities are confirmed for each property.

Request your free property review