← All articles

THE OWNER'S NOTEBOOK · CHOOSING A MANAGER

8 questions to ask a vacation rental property manager.

A clearer way to compare proposals, understand the costs and find the right support for your vacation home.

Comparing management proposals? Ask each provider the same questions, then compare the scope, evidence and responsibilities behind the answers. Use this checklist with any prospective manager, including Roava.

Start with the total cost, who looks after guests and the home, how you stay informed, and what happens if you leave. A clear written answer is more useful than a broad promise.

01

What does the management fee actually cover?

Ask for a written scope that separates work included in the fee, work coordinated for an extra charge, and work left to you. Guest messaging, pricing, listing updates, cleaning coordination and on-site response are separate responsibilities. A promise of full service is easier to evaluate when each responsibility has a named person or team.

Request: an itemized scope, support hours and a list of excluded services.

02

Which revenue is the fee calculated on?

Two identical percentages can produce different charges. Ask whether the fee applies to accommodation revenue only, or also to cleaning and other guest charges. Confirm how refunds, discounts, platform charges and canceled stays affect the calculation. Compare proposals using the same assumed bookings and expenses rather than comparing percentages alone.

Request: a worked example showing guest payment, each deduction and the resulting owner payout.

03

Who checks the home between stays?

Ask who confirms that cleaning is complete, checks access instructions, spots missing supplies and reports damage before the next guest arrives. Clarify what happens if the usual cleaner cannot attend. For a home with a pool, hot tub or large outdoor area, ask how those features fit into the turnover plan and which specialist services cost extra.

Request: a turnover checklist, an inspection process and the backup coverage plan.

04

How are pricing decisions made?

Ask how the manager chooses comparable properties and responds to seasonality, booking lead time and gaps in the calendar. An automated pricing tool is one part of the process; you also need to know who reviews its decisions. Discuss minimum acceptable rates, owner-use dates and how unusual demand or extended vacancies are handled.

Request: a sample pricing review with its assumptions, rather than an unsupported revenue promise.

05

What happens when a guest needs help?

Separate message response from help at the property. Ask who answers an evening lockout, who can attend a heating issue, and when you would be contacted. For a Michigan vacation home, discuss the arrangements relevant to the property, such as winter access, seasonal systems or a remote location. Do not assume that every manager offers the same local coverage.

Request: the escalation steps, response arrangements and spending approvals for urgent work.

06

What will I see in my owner statement?

Ask for an anonymized statement that connects reservations to income, fees, refunds, vendor bills and the amount paid to the owner. Confirm the reporting and payout schedule. Discuss how you can ask about an unfamiliar charge and how maintenance approvals are recorded. An occupancy figure alone does not explain what ownership costs or what you receive.

Request: a sample statement, a sample maintenance record and the reporting schedule.

07

What happens to listings and bookings if I switch?

Before making changes, establish who controls each listing, photography, calendar and account. List upcoming reservations and agree who will communicate with guests and service each stay during a handover. Platform rules and the existing agreement affect the available options; do not assume that listings, reviews or reservations can simply be transferred.

Request: an account-access inventory and a written handover plan before changing permissions or canceling services.

08

How will we decide whether the arrangement is working?

Agree which outcomes matter to you: clearer reporting, less coordination, better property care or a stronger approach to pricing. Ask how concerns are raised, how often the plan is reviewed and what information supports a proposed change. Discuss the agreement duration, notice requirements and end-of-service responsibilities with the provider before you commit.

Request: a review schedule, agreed priorities and the terms in writing.

PUT THE ANSWERS TO WORK

How to compare vacation rental management proposals

After the interviews, give each provider the same property brief: sleeping capacity, amenities, owner-use dates, current booking channels and the work you want to hand over. Ask them to confirm which assumptions their proposal uses. A larger service package and a messaging-only arrangement solve different problems, even when both use the word management.

Make one comparison record for each manager.

Copy these five prompts into your notes. For every answer, record the supporting document and any point still awaiting confirmation. Treat an unanswered question as unresolved, rather than assuming the service is included.

Scope and people
Included tasks: ____. Extra-charge tasks: ____. Tasks I keep: ____. Person responsible for each: ____.
Costs and assumptions
Fee calculation base: ____. Fixed charges: ____. Cleaning, supplies and maintenance charges: ____. Example statement received: ____.
Property response
Guest contact: ____. Person who can attend the home: ____. Backup arrangements: ____. Owner approval process: ____.
Visibility and control
Calendar access: ____. Reporting schedule: ____. Listing account owner: ____. Photo-use permissions: ____.
Open questions
What needs clarification: ____. Who will answer: ____. Date to follow up: ____.

Compare vacation rental management fees using the same inputs.

Ask each provider to calculate its quote against the same sample month before comparing percentages. Keep accommodation revenue, guest cleaning charges, platform deductions and owner-paid expenses on separate lines. Have the provider identify exactly which lines count toward its management fee. Words such as gross revenue and net revenue need a written definition in that proposal.

Hypothetical example, not Roava pricing or a market benchmark: suppose a sample month has $4,000 in accommodation charges and $500 in guest cleaning charges. An invented 20% fee applied only to accommodation is $800. The same 20% applied to both lines is $900. The $100 difference comes entirely from the calculation base, with identical bookings and the same quoted percentage.

This example isolates one question. It does not compare complete service packages or predict a property's income. Next, add each proposal's separate fixed charges and excluded services using the same assumptions. Ask whether cleaning collections cover the cleaning invoice, who pays any shortfall, and whether supplies or maintenance coordination are included. Record unknown costs as unresolved rather than entering zero.

Separate a quote comparison from a revenue forecast.

If a provider supplies its own revenue estimate, keep that in a separate scenario. Ask which comparable homes, available nights, owner-use dates and seasonal assumptions support it. For a Michigan vacation home, make the available season and owner stays explicit. A larger forecast can hide a more expensive fee arrangement when the two proposals assume different booking revenue.

Request two clearly labeled views: the charges calculated on your shared sample and the provider's forecast with its assumptions. Neither is a guarantee. Also list work you retain, such as arranging repairs or answering an overnight call. A lower calculated charge does not settle which service scope fits your needs.

Before deciding, ask: Can you show the fee base, each separate charge, excluded work and the supporting proposal clause on one sample calculation? Use our owner-statement guide to understand how actual deductions and payouts are later reported.

Walk through the same three situations.

  • A late arrival cannot enter the home. Ask who receives the message, what remote troubleshooting is available and who can attend if it fails.
  • A turnover reveals a problem before check-in. Ask who decides whether the home is ready, who arranges the fix, how the guest is updated and when the owner approves spending.
  • You want to reserve a week for your family. Ask how owner stays are requested, how existing reservations are checked and what preparation or cleaning charges apply.

For a Michigan property, add one scenario that matches the home: a snowy driveway, a seasonal water system or an arrival after local service providers close. Ask for coverage at the property's actual location and season. A provider's regional marketing does not establish who will reach your home.

Keep access permissions separate from the service promise.

For Airbnb, co-host access can range from viewing the calendar to full access. Those settings determine what someone can do on the platform; they do not establish which services your manager has agreed to deliver. Match the permissions to the written scope and confirm the listing owner before changing access. See Airbnb's explanation of co-host permissions for the current options.

Finally, identify the two or three responsibilities you most want to stop handling yourself. Compare the written answers against those priorities. Where a proposal is unclear, request clarification before choosing; a polished presentation alone cannot resolve a missing operating plan.

Explore Roava's management services and bring your questions to a property-specific review.

For a detailed monthly review, read how to read a vacation rental owner statement.

BEFORE YOUR FIRST CONVERSATION

Bring three things.

Your property details or current listing, the tasks you want help with, and an example of what is not working today. If you already have a manager, have the current scope and fee schedule available for your own comparison. Avoid sharing guest personal information.

Roava starts with a property-specific review. Fees, local support and the final service scope are confirmed individually; there is no published standard management rate or guaranteed revenue outcome.

Request your free property review
← Back to the journal